Field Guides
What the THC percentage can and cannot tell you
By SŌMA 7 min read Updated
On a New York flower label, total THC is one of the few things the front of the package must show, and buyers weigh it. In a 2018 survey of cannabis users in seven US states, THC ranked fourth among 20 things they said mattered when buying, after quality, the type and price. In Washington State's sales data for 2014 to 2016, flower with more THC sold for slightly more per gram: about 1–2% more for each percentage point of THC.
The figure tells you something about strength. It says little about aroma, flavour or freshness, and even as a measure of strength it is less exact than it looks. This guide explains what the figure does and does not tell you; its sources are listed at the end.
What the number measures
New York labels give total THC: THC plus THCA multiplied by 0.877, as a percentage of the flower's weight. The plant makes its cannabinoids as acids such as THCA, and heat turns THCA into THC, the compound New York's Office of Cannabis Management (OCM) describes as known for the feeling of being high. A shop's menu may give a different measure, such as THCA alone; our QR code guide explains how to tell which.
The figure comes from a lab's test of a sample from the batch. Since July 2023, New York has required approved sampling firms to collect the samples, which must represent the lot. The lab certificate gives the day the sample was collected, and OCM's label guide warns that a certificate will not be accurate forever, because cannabis can change when it is exposed to air.
What it is good for
Strength. OCM's label guide says that different products have different amounts of THC and other cannabinoids, and that the amount can change how a product affects you. OCM's advice for anything new is to start low and go slow: wait 5 to 10 minutes after one or two puffs before having more.
Even here the figure is a rough guide, because people adjust, though not in one consistent way. In a study of people using their own cannabis at home, those whose cannabis was higher in THC rolled less of it into a joint. In another, of heavy users, those with stronger cannabis rolled more of it into a joint, and inhaled less smoke from stronger joints, though not enough to make up the difference, so they still took in more THC. In a Colorado study of regular users who used as much as they chose, those assigned flower of 24% THC did not differ from those assigned 16% in reported intoxication or in its tests of memory, attention and balance.
Why the number can mislead
- It varies under one name. Flower sold under one strain name varies in THC from sample to sample: a study of Washington data calls strain names a meaningful but variable signal of THC and CBD. See Why the same strain can feel different.
- Labs differ. In Washington State's testing data, some labs consistently reported higher cannabinoid levels than others, and the differences remained after accounting for the producer, the strain name and the date.
- They differ on the same material. When the US National Institute of Standards and Technology sent the same plant samples to many labs, most labs agreed with themselves on repeat tests, but results between labs spread more widely than AOAC International's performance criterion: for total THC in the three samples NIST classed as marijuana, the relative standard deviation between labs was 10.3% to 13.0%, against a criterion of 10% or less. Those samples held far less THC than flower on a shop shelf, and the labs used different methods, to which that criterion is not strictly meant to apply.
- Results bunch above 20%. In Nevada and Washington, reported THC results jumped just above 20%, a threshold buyers and shops are reported to favour; in Washington the jump came from some labs and not others.
- Labels can run high. When researchers retested 23 flower samples from 10 Colorado dispensaries, about 70% measured more than 15% below the lowest THC figure on the label. The authors found too little CBN, THC's breakdown product, for age to explain it. It was a small study, in one state.
- One plant is not even. In one study, flowers from the top of the plant held close to twice the THC of those from the bottom, so a result depends on which flowers were sampled. New York's sampling rules are meant to keep samples representative of the lot.
- It ages. THC breaks down after the test, faster with light, air and warmth; see Why freshness matters.
Most of these studies come from other states. New York's own rules allow a margin: under OCM's testing limits, a lab's potency result for an adult-use product must fall between 85% and 115% of the potency on its label. On a label reading 25% total THC, that is anything from 21.25% to 28.75%. OCM says lab testing ensures products are accurately labelled for potency; we found no published study that retested New York flower against its label or compared New York labs.
What it does not tell you
- Aroma and flavour. OCM describes terpenes as the compounds that provide cannabis its aroma, and the THC figure does not measure them. In a six-state study of lab results for THC-dominant flower with terpene data, samples fell into three main terpene groups with similar THC levels, so the THC figure alone would not tell you which group a jar belongs to.
- Whether you will like it. We found one study on this. In survey answers from volunteer judges at cannabis competitions, who were given flower samples double-blind, how pleasant people found the effects went with how pleasant they found the aroma, and not with the THC figure or the amount of THC taken. It is one observational study, several of its authors list private companies as their affiliation, and we read only its abstract.
- How it was grown, dried and stored. The certificate reports cannabinoids and terpenes and tests for contaminants; it does not say how the flower was grown or dried, or how it has been kept since the sample was taken. See How to store cannabis.
What to read beside it
- The terpenes on the lab certificate. OCM's testing rules require every final product, flower included, to be tested for terpenes; the label itself must show a terpene profile only when terpenes are marketed.
- The packaged and test dates in the Metrc Retail ID record. A New York label must give an expiration date, not a harvest or packaging date; our QR code guide shows where to find the others.
- Who made it: a New York label names the processor and its licence number.
- The aroma when you open the package, and your own notes on what you liked, by aroma and effect rather than by number.
How treats potency
SŌMA does not rank flower by THC. The Strains catalogue can be filtered by strength, but it sorts by match, by curation or by name, and Match orders a menu by its score. That score leans mostly on aroma, flavour and effect; if you tell My taste that you prefer milder or stronger flower, potency counts as a small adjustment. SŌMA's strength levels are a researcher's judgement on a researched record and, for other names, come from the median THC on New York lab certificates for the grower's lots, where SŌMA holds them. More in How SŌMA works.
Sources
- Zhu and others, “Perceived importance of factors in cannabis purchase decisions: a best-worst scaling experiment”, International Journal of Drug Policy, 2021.
- Smart and others, “Variation in cannabis potency and prices in a newly legal market: evidence from 30 million cannabis sales in Washington state”, Addiction, 2017.
- 9 NYCRR Parts 128 and 129, Adult-Use Packaging and Labeling, adopted text: sections 128.1(ac) and 128.5(a) and (b).
- How to read an adult-use cannabis label in New York (013-OCM-EN), Office of Cannabis Management.
- How to read a lab certificate of analysis for your cannabis product, Office of Cannabis Management.
- Laboratory testing guidance for adult-use licensees, revised 12 June 2024, Office of Cannabis Management.
- Cannabis testing limits, revision of 9 February 2026, Office of Cannabis Management: table 1.
- Consumers, Office of Cannabis Management: “Consuming Cannabis Responsibly”.
- Milay and others, “Metabolic profiling of cannabis secondary metabolites for evaluation of optimal postharvest storage conditions”, Frontiers in Plant Science, 2020.
- Freeman and others, “Just say ‘know’: how do cannabinoid concentrations influence users' estimates of cannabis potency and the amount they roll in joints?”, Addiction, 2014: abstract.
- van der Pol and others, “Cross-sectional and prospective relation of cannabis potency, dosing and smoking behaviour with cannabis dependence: an ecological study”, Addiction, 2014: abstract.
- Bidwell and others, “Association of naturalistic administration of cannabis flower and concentrates with intoxication and impairment”, JAMA Psychiatry, 2020: key points and abstract.
- Jikomes and Zoorob, “The cannabinoid content of legal cannabis in Washington State varies systematically across testing facilities and popular consumer products”, Scientific Reports, 2018.
- Cannabis Laboratory Quality Assurance Program, Exercise 2 final report (NIST IR 8519), National Institute of Standards and Technology, June 2024: executive summary.
- Zoorob, “The frequency distribution of reported THC concentrations of legal cannabis flower products increases discontinuously around the 20% THC threshold in Nevada and Washington state”, Journal of Cannabis Research, 2021: abstract.
- Schwabe and others, “Uncomfortably high: testing reveals inflated THC potency on retail Cannabis labels”, PLoS ONE, 2023.
- Richins and others, “Accumulation of bioactive metabolites in cultivated medical Cannabis”, PLoS ONE, 2018.
- Smith and others, “The phytochemical diversity of commercial Cannabis in the United States”, PLoS ONE, 2022.
- Plumb and others, “The nose knows: aroma, but not THC mediates the subjective effects of smoked and vaporized Cannabis flower”, Psychoactives, 2022: abstract.
- How SŌMA works: how Match scores a menu.
Frequently asked questions
Does a higher THC percentage mean better flower?
Not by itself. The figure measures one compound in a lab's sample of the batch. It tells you something about strength, not about aroma, flavour, freshness or how the flower was grown and kept, and studies in other states found it varies from lab to lab.
Why do THC numbers vary so much?
Flower differs from batch to batch and even from the top of a plant to the bottom; labs differ in what they report; and THC breaks down over time. New York allows a lab's result for an adult-use product to fall between 85% and 115% of the potency on its label. Because of that variation, a single figure is a weak basis for comparing two products on a shelf.
Is the THC on a menu the same as on the label?
Not always. A New York label gives total THC, THC plus THCA × 0.877; a menu is the shop's own listing and may give THCA alone, which is a different number. Our QR code guide explains how to compare them.
What should I look at besides THC?
The terpenes on the lab certificate, which New York requires labs to test for, the packaged and test dates in the Metrc Retail ID record, who made it, the aroma when you open the package, and your own notes on what you liked. With anything new, start low and go slow.
Does rank strains by potency?
No. Match orders flower by its score, which rests mostly on aroma, flavour and effect; if you tell My taste that you prefer milder or stronger flower, potency counts as a small adjustment. The Strains catalogue can be filtered by strength but is never sorted by it.
Corrections
- We said the THC percentage is the loudest number on any dispensary menu, that it sorts the shelf, sets the price and, for many buyers, makes the decision, and that it is one of the weakest predictors of whether you will enjoy what you take home; and, in the description, that it is the first thing most people look at and one of the least useful. We had no source for the loudest number, the first look, sorting the shelf or making the decision; the evidence we found on price is from Washington State in 2014–2016, not New York; and for enjoyment we found only one observational study, whose abstract we could read. The guide now says what we could source: that New York labels must show total THC on the front, that buyers in one survey ranked THC fourth among 20 factors, that flower with more THC sold for slightly more per gram in Washington State, and what that one study found.
- We described the figure as roughly how much of the intoxicating cannabinoid was present, and said it is not a measure of how the flower will feel. A New York label gives total THC, which counts THCA as well as THC, and the Office of Cannabis Management says the amount of THC can change how a product affects you. The guide now says what total THC is, that a menu may give a different measure, and that the figure tells you something about strength, if roughly.
- We said the figure varies between labs testing the same batch, that aroma and flavour are where most of the character lives, and that the figure ignores how flower was grown, cured and stored, the things that decide whether it arrives lively or flat. The guide now gives what studies found about differences between labs, on the same material and within one plant, and no longer says where the character lives or what decides how flower arrives, which we could not source.
- We said chasing the highest number tends to narrow your shelf to a handful of similar products, and that people who describe their best sessions rarely describe them in percentages. We found no source for either and removed them.
- We said that past a certain point more potency mostly changes the dose you need, not the experience you get. Studies of how people adjust disagree: one found people rolled less of stronger cannabis into a joint, another that heavy users rolled more of it and inhaled less smoke, not enough to offset it; and one found no difference in reported intoxication between 16% and 24% THC flower among regular users who used as much as they chose. The guide now gives those findings instead.
- We advised reading the aroma and effect description and looking for a recent harvest or packaging date. A listing's description is the seller's, not a measurement, and New York's label rules require an expiration date, not a harvest or packaging date. The guide now points to the terpenes on the lab certificate, the aroma itself, and the packaged and test dates in the Metrc Retail ID record.
- We said SŌMA deliberately does not rank flower by potency and matches on aroma, flavour and effect because that is what you will remember afterwards. SŌMA does not rank by THC, but Strains can be filtered by strength, and if you state a preference for milder or stronger flower, Match counts potency as a small adjustment. We had no source for what you will remember. The guide and the FAQ now say what SŌMA does.
- In the FAQ we said flower with a lower figure can easily be the more enjoyable product, depending on how it was grown, cured and stored. We had no source for it and removed it.
- We titled this guide “Why the THC percentage is a poor guide to good flower” and said in the introduction that this is why we call it a poor guide. The title read as a verdict on quality, which the guide does not make: it is about what the figure measures and how exact it is. It is now titled “What the THC percentage can and cannot tell you”; its address is unchanged.